Posts tagged "lennart knows best"

Show Your Working: Turning off PulseAudio "flat volumes"

Sun 23 July 2017

PulseAudio volume control application with awful "flat volumes" behavior

Show Your Working is a brand new segment where I write up things I have attempted to fix in open source software. Sometimes it's interesting to debug a problem yourself from first principles, even if the codebase is huge and you don't know anything going in. I will try and explain my thought process as I venture out into the weeds armed only with a butter knife.

The software

PulseAudio is the software audio mixer for most desktop Linux distributions. Let's not mince words; PulseAudio has an awful reputation, mostly earned from the botched rollout by Ubuntu and other distributions back in 2008. Long-time Linux users remember these as the dark years where games were unplayable, and everything was punctuated by a loud crackling from the constant buffer underruns. The most egregious problems were caused by the aforementioned shonky buffering, plus a reliance on timing-related ALSA features which had never been used/tested properly for many sound drivers. It didn't help that barely any applications had direct support for the PulseAudio API; there were compatibility shims for ALSA/OSS applications, but they were a crapshoot at best.

But that was a decade ago! We've moved from version 0.9 to version 11.1, a metric ass-ton of effort has gone into making the mixer first rate, most Linux sound libraries are fully Pulse compatible, etc. etc. Surely everything is perfect now, right?

Article continues here! KEEP READING, YOU